For this week’s reflection post, I would like to focus on the following online elements: entire class discussion and group discussion. While these two activities are seemingly very similar, in practice they were extremely different learning experiences.
The entire class discussion forum was on the verge of being overwhelming. I am not sure how many total posts there were, but with around fifty people posting and commenting, keeping close tabs on every conversation soon felt untenable. This was, perhaps surprisingly, not frustrating to me as a learner. Instead of trying to read every thread, I skimmed and scanned the forum looking for the conversations that most interested me and to which I felt I had the most to contribute. It was something like flipping through channels on a television. Some channels I skipped right over. Others I lingered on for a few moments. Still others drew me in, luring me to check back in even after my obligations were completed. The chance to explore and reflect on so much content was beneficial to me. The biggest challenge, as noted earlier, was the sheer volume of posts, but I did not feel the need to read everything, and was therefore not really negatively impacted. I would definitely use this element in my classroom without any change (other than the topic). That said, the prompt seemed key. The open-endedness seemed absolutely essential for the forum to flourish. As an EMLS instructor, my challenge is to consider how this online element could be successful in my teaching context, where students are often reluctant to write. I think the key, as noted above, is asking the right questions. In an EMLS reading class, I could have students share a captivating quote from the novel they are reading. They could post the sentence and explain why they chose it and what thoughts it inspires. In my context especially, this would need to be clearly modeled. I would likely provide a sample in the instructions and then require students post before viewing their peers’ responses. This would encourage a wide variety of responses, making the thread more interesting to read. The group forums were a bit of a mixed bag for me. I had a bit of difficulty with the OEI Rubric group discussion forum. While it included specific instructions, I had difficulty understanding the expectations. Also, it seemed as though we needed to work together as a group to decide what to discuss before discussing it, which I found problematic in an asynchronous environment as the participants in the course have a wide variety of schedules. This created a fair amount of inertia to overcome. Also, I noticed that at least one peer interpreted the instructions differently than I had. All of this left me feeling confused about how to approach the assignment. Finally, only three people out of our group of five participated in that particular forum, and one of those only posted once. Interestingly, the Week 3 discussion group went much better for me. I had a better understanding of the expectations and the group participation was stronger. This provides me with two takeaways. First, the clarity of directions is absolutely key in an effective group discussion. Also, it is important to make groups large enough so that, even if a couple of people do not participate, the discussion can still thrive. Knowing my student population, I probably would not put them in groups of fewer than five, but would try to keep group sizes at seven or eight. Of course, this would greatly depend on the specific course and group of students in question. All in all, I have enjoyed experiencing so many elements and considering how I could use them in my own classroom and I look forward to exploring them further.
0 Comments
As I reflect on the first week of this course, am was most struck by the robust forum posts by many of my peers. While deviating from the 100 word limit will probably make them more difficult to grade, I appreciated the thoughtful exploration of a topic that is incredibly nuanced and complex.
I am often frustrated by discussions of online education. There are those who dismiss it out of hand, conflating online education with lazy teachers and unmotivated students together exchanging money for meaningless certificates. At the other extreme are teachers who see online teaching as a panacea for all of education's ills, with little regard for the difficulties of implementation and a naivete towards the problems that confront instructors and students. What I saw in the forums represented the best of these conversations. There was a recognition of the benefits of both online and face-to-face learning and the conversation seemed rooted in the basic questions of what we are trying to accomplish as educators. This is clearly a cohort that desires that students engage with the content, one another, and the world at large. Numerous issues with online education were brought up, but the conversation was one of imagination and possibility, not resignation. I am looking forward to next week. |
AuthorI am currently taking a class about best practices in online teaching. This is a blog to share my reflections. ArchivesCategories |